HIH Studios

Wednesday, May 17, 2006

A comparison of 8 KHz mono audio formats

8KHz mono audio formats

Audio format

16-bit PCM

G.711 mu-law

32Kbps MPEG-1

IMA/DVI ADPCM

GSM 06.10

InterWave VSC112

TrueSpeech 8.5

RealAudio v1.0

ToolVox for the Web

File extension

.wav or .aiff

.au

.mpa or .mp2

.wav

.gsm

.vmf

.wav

.ra

.vox

Data rate

128Kbps

64Kbps

32Kbps

32Kbps

13.2Kbps

11.2Kbps

8.5Kbps

8Kbps

2.4Kbps

File size per minute

960K

480K

240K

240K

96K

82K

62K

59K

18K

Compression factor

1:1

2:1

4:1

4:1

10:1

11:1

15:1

16:1

53:1

Sound quality

5 (sample)

4 (sample)

4 (sample)

3 (sample)

2 (sample)

2 (sample)

2 (sample)

1 (sample)

0-3 (sample)

Relative compression speed

N/A

10

(not tested)

1.2

0.75

3

0.5

0.2

0.25

Windows player

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Mac player

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

Yes

Unix player

Yes

Yes

Yes

Some

Yes

No

No

only v2.0

Promised

Supports higher sample rates

Yes

Yes, but rarely used

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

No

in v2.0

in other products

Streaming playback file

None

None

None

None

.gsd

.vmd

.tsp

.ram

None

Credits

None

None

None

None

None

In .vmd file

None

In .ra file

None

No comments: